![]() |
Photo captured an era, but not a moment
Everyone knows Rosa Parks. Only a family knows the man behind her.
06:57 AM CST on Friday, December 9, 2005
RIDGEWOOD, N.J. – Almost everyone has seen the famous study in black and white, one of those rare photographs that enters the collective memory as a snapshot not of a moment, but of an era and maybe something more. It's now on almost any bus in New York City and many of its suburbs, an invitation not just to remember, but to reflect. At the front of a bus, where black people had never ridden before, is Rosa Parks, head slightly bowed, face turned to the window to her left, seemingly lost in thought as she rides through Montgomery, Ala. In the seat behind her, like the symbol of the old segregated order, is a young white man looking to his right, his face hard, almost expressionless. The two, the only figures visible on the bus, seem a few inches and a universe apart, each seemingly looking at and for something utterly different. Everyone knows her. No one knows him. Except for Catherine Chriss, his daughter. And, like his identity, hidden in plain sight, unknown even to the veterans of that era still living, what's most telling about the real story of the black woman and the white man is how much of what we think we know is what we read into the picture, not what's there. The man on the bus, Nicholas C. Chriss, was not some irritated Alabama segregationist preserved for history, but a reporter working at the time for United Press International out of Atlanta. He died of an aneurysm at age 62 in 1990. Mrs. Parks died at age 92 on Oct. 24, a few weeks short of the 50th anniversary of her refusal to give up her seat on the bus to a white man. Ms. Chriss, a journalist currently caring for her three young daughters, in November wrote a poem about the picture and the way her father became "the white man. The angry man. The one who looks like he's a banker. But isn't." Over the past few years, she's been amazed at how ubiquitous the picture has become. "It's everywhere," said Ms. Chriss, whose family moved to Ridgewood from California in 2004. "Apple used it in their campaign, 'Think Different.' A friend called and said she saw the poster on the bus, the whole bus. It's on the bus my daughter Alison takes to school now. When Alison was in second grade, her classroom had that border with African-American heroes and leaders, and there's the picture. She told her teacher that was her granddad up there. She didn't believe her." Mr. Chriss, who also worked for the Los Angeles Times and the Houston Chronicle, publicly revealed his role in the picture just once. It was three paragraphs in the middle of a 2,183-word article he wrote for the Houston Chronicle in 1986 about his experiences covering the civil rights movement. He explained the picture was taken on Dec. 21, 1956, the day after the U.S. Supreme Court ruled Montgomery's segregated bus system illegal. (Actually, the ruling had come a month earlier, but it was not until Dec. 20 that the district court entered the order putting it into effect.) He said he boarded the bus in downtown Montgomery, and he and Mrs. Parks were the only riders up front. He wrote: "It was a historic occasion. I was then with the United Press International wire service. A UPI photographer took a picture of Mrs. Parks on the bus. It shows a somber Mrs. Parks seated on the bus looking calmly out the window. Seated just behind her is a hard-eyed white man. Each anniversary of that day, this photograph is brought out of musty files and used in various publications around the world. But to this day no one has ever made clear that it was a reporter, I, covering this event and sitting behind Mrs. Parks, not some sullen white segregationist! "It was a great scoop for me, but Mrs. Parks had little to say. She seemed to want to savor the event alone." But his role in the picture was not included in his obituary, and interviews with almost a dozen veterans of that era – historians; reporters; photographers; book publishers; the Montgomery civil rights attorney, Fred Gray, who represented Mrs. Parks in court – did not turn up a single one who knew the man's identity. Still, if little known, the history of the picture is explored in one source, the biography of Rosa Parks by Douglas Brinkley, first published in 2000 as part of the Penguin Lives series of biographies. Mr. Brinkley said Mrs. Parks, in interviews with him, said she left her home at the Cleveland Courts housing project specifically for a picture of her on a bus and that the idea was for her to be seated in the front of the bus with a white man behind. Similar photo opportunities were arranged for the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr. and others during the day, he said. Mr. Chriss then agreed to sit behind her for the purpose of the picture. Mr. Brinkley does not identify Mr. Chriss in the book and attributes the picture to a reporter for Look magazine and two photographers from Look. He said Mrs. Parks told him she was reluctant to take part in the picture, but both the journalists and members of the civil rights community wanted an image that would dramatize what had occurred. "It was completely a 100 percent staged event," Mr. Brinkley said. "There was nothing random about it." But then the images and history of that era, so stark and powerful on their own, are seldom so simple. For starters, many people assume the famous picture of Mrs. Parks captures the events of Dec. 1, 1955, when she refused to give up her seat on a packed bus to a white man. Not true. The other famous images of her, a mug shot and a picture of her being fingerprinted, don't date to Dec. 1, 1955, either. They were taken on Feb. 20, 1956, when about 100 Montgomery blacks were indicted for violating a local anti-boycott statute. Mrs. Parks was not the first black bus rider in Montgomery to refuse to give up her seat. Two other women, Claudette Colvin and Mary Louise Smith, had done it in previous months, but Mrs. Parks' case became the one the legal challenge was based upon. The triumphant case from Montgomery that declared the city's segregated bus system illegal was not based on her case, but on that of four other plaintiffs, including Ms. Colvin and Ms. Smith. And rather than a simple seamstress who dared to "Think Different," Mrs. Parks was a longtime NAACP activist, who went to the famous Highlander Folk School to learn about social change and lunched regularly with Mr. Gray, the civil rights lawyer. None of that lessens the achievement or her life, just as, perhaps, the true story of her picture with Mr. Chriss need not detract from its power. It's just a reminder that history is almost always more complicated and surprising than the images that most effectively tell its story.
Taxpayers pay millions for unapproved drugs in Medicaid plan, study says
Astronauts try to work out kinks in urine machine
Gunfire at Wash. shopping mall kills 1, wounds 1
Obama wants tax cuts in January but not as big as signaled earlier, aide says
Disgraced Colo. pastor Haggard returns, as Christian businessman
Latest News
Most Emailed Stories
Latest Video




